Mr. President, Your Excellencies,
I am honoured to present before the Security Council the eighth report of the President of the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia, in accordance with Security Council resolution 1534 of 2004. In my address to you today, I will highlight the most significant points of the report submitted on 12 November 2007, which provides a detailed account of the progress made by the International Tribunal in achieving the objectives of the Completion Strategy from June to November 2007. I will also offer an assessment of the work that remains to be completed in light of ongoing challenges to the finalization of the International Tribunal's historic mandate and of developments since the submission of the report.
Before reviewing the International Tribunal's activities during the past six months, Mr. President, allow me to personally thank you for the unwavering support shown by your [and my] country, Italy, to the important work of the International Tribunal. Italy's commitment to the international community's fight against impunity has been unremitting and will remain all the more crucial as the International Tribunal completes its mission. Indeed, Italy's support, as well as that of the other members of the Security Council, is critical to ensuring the lasting legacy of the International Tribunal's unique achievements.
The International Tribunal will leave an incredibly rich and important legacy to current and future international criminal jurisdictions, in substantive, procedural and institutional terms. Many parts of the report offer perfect examples of these realizations.
The first accomplishment I wish to highlight is the International Tribunal's unparalleled efficiency in the conduct of international criminal proceedings. Out of the 161 accused indicted by the International Tribunal, trial and appeal proceedings against 111 accused have been completed. Of the 50 accused whose cases remain to be completed, four remain at large, eight accused have pending appeals, 27 have commenced trial and 11 are currently in the pre-trial stage. Two contempt proceedings have also been initiated. The dramatic increase shown in these figures, particularly in the last years, clearly surpasses any reasonable expectation.
During the reporting period, the three trial Chambers continued to operate at record capacity, conducting additional hearings during the three-week summer recess. Taking advantage of the fact that one of these trials has entered into the phase of judgement drafting and does not therefore necessitate a courtroom, the International Tribunal was able to start the trial of Vojislav Šešelj on 7 November 2007, bringing to eight the number of cases simultaneously handled in trial phase. This was further made possible because all the members of the trial bench in that case are currently sitting in two trials.
The Appeals Chamber has also increased its productivity in relation to both the International Tribunal and the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda (ICTR). For 2007, it has so far rendered 235 written decisions and 15 Judgements including four review or referral appeals and, since the submission of my written report, two additional ICTR Judgements on the merits.
This efficiency is attributable in part to the implementation of the various measures adopted to speed up trial and appellate proceedings. This report shows the significant impact that previously adopted measures have had on the expeditiousness of our proceedings. For example, some of the rules that were recently adopted have enabled Trial Chambers to prune indictments, such as in the D. Milosević case; to reduce the time allocated to Prosecution and Defence cases, such as in the Milutinović et al. case; and to remove witnesses from the proposed witness list whose evidence was deemed repetitive, such as in the Boškoski and Tarčulovski case. In the pre-trial phase of the Perišić case, the Trial Chamber also invited the Prosecution to cut down its case by a third, which resulted in the dropping of 22 witnesses and a reduction of the estimated duration of the Prosecution case by 169 hours. Other recently amended rules, which enable a Trial Chamber to admit written evidence under certain conditions, have been regularly applied in the D. Milosević, Popović et al., and Haradinaj et al. cases and have led to a substantial reduction of the average length of in court examinations.
In addition to these measures, we have continued to explore new ways to further streamline trial and appeals procedures. At the last ordinary plenary session of 12 July 2007, two other rule amendments were adopted, providing for greater use of testimony by video-link and specifying timelines for the filing of pre-trial motions for unrepresented accused.
To summarize, at this time, there remain only 11 accused in seven cases awaiting trial before the International Tribunal. This net increase of two accused awaiting trial since the last report is attributable to the arrest of two fugitives, Tolimir and Đorđević. Furthermore, the decision of the Appeals Chamber to reverse the referral of Milan Lukić under Rule 11bis has also led to the decision to retain his co-accused Sredoje Lukić. This increase has required the International Tribunal to adjust its forecast. It is expected that, with the exception of the two recent arrivals, the International Tribunal will be able to complete all of its trials, including the Lukić & Lukić case, by the end of 2009. The trials of the two recent arrivals are estimated to finish in early 2010 but all appeals can still be concluded within 2011. I must stress that such minor adjustments are attributable to these new late arrivals and that, as I just indicated, the overall efficiency of the International Tribunal has in fact increased.
Let me also emphasize that none of the achievements that I have just mentioned could have been accomplished without the full dedication of all of our Judges and of our staff. Their longstanding experience and exceptional qualifications is yet another contribution the International Tribunal will continue to make to the field of international criminal justice, long after we close our doors. The International Tribunal has in fact set the example for other international criminal jurisdictions, elaborating and developing, for instance, rules that ensure the fair and expeditious conduct of international criminal proceedings. The International Tribunal has also lent concrete support to other international criminal jurisdictions, through loans and transfers of staff and through the conduct of training workshops.
In this regard, I cannot sufficiently underscore the importance of retaining our experienced Judges in order to meet completion strategy goals. Many of the International Tribunal's Judges are currently serving their second term while a few are in their third term. It is crucial that the conditions of service of Judges are correctly implemented as far as pensions are concerned. In this regard, I must convey the judges' disappointment with the delays suffered in the commissioning of the study on options for designing pension schemes for Judges of the International Tribunal. The longer it takes for this question to be favourably resolved by Member States, the greater the risk of losing some of the most experienced Judges, who will feel compelled to leave the International Tribunal to secure pension entitlements in their national jurisdictions. Needless to say, such departures would seriously affect the timely and efficient completion of the International Tribunal's work.
I must also caution that during the reporting period the number of staff leaving the International Tribunal for more secure employment with other institutions has increased. While the International Tribunal has managed to minimize delays in recruitment by using the roster system, some delays are inevitable and will probably increase. This will undoubtedly have a detrimental impact on the expeditious completion of the International Tribunal's mandate. I would therefore urge the Security Council and Member States to support the International Tribunal in its efforts to offer sufficient incentives to guarantee, as much as possible, that its best staff remain until the work of the International Tribunal is completed.
Finally, I want to stress the importance of the work done by our ad litem Judges. Of our twelve ad litem Judges, two are serving both as ad litem Judge on one trial and reserve ad litem Judge on an additional trial, while two ad litem Judges are serving on two trials. Three ad litem Judges have begun hearing an additional trial while drafting the Judgement in another case, thus serving on two, and in one instance even three cases full time. In other words, all twelve ad litem Judges have been willing to take on an onerous workload to ensure the expeditious completion of the International Tribunal's mandate.
Let me now turn to our partnership with domestic courts. As you well know, the referral of intermediate and lower-ranking accused to competent national jurisdictions, which is provided for under Rule 11bis,was developed in the context of the completion strategy. However, the success of the referral procedure also stands to be a key indicator of our commitment to sharing know-how with domestic courts, in particular in the former Yugoslavia, along with our involvement in capacity-building and outreach activities in the region.
As I have previously reported, the referral process has had a substantial impact on our workload. While there have been no new referrals during this reporting period, thirteen accused have now been transferred for trial before the domestic courts in the former Yugoslavia. Ten accused have been transferred to the Special War Crimes Chamber of Bosnia and Herzegovina, two accused have been transferred to the authorities of Croatia and one accused has been transferred to Serbia. Two accused, Milan and Sredoje Lukić, whose referrals had been requested by the Prosecution, will instead be tried by the International Tribunal.
Rule 11bis provides that the Prosecution has the authority to request the Referral Bench to revoke a referral, should it determine that a case is not being conducted in accordance with human rights norms and due process standards. Of the cases referred by the International Tribunal, the Special War Crimes Chamber of Bosnia and Herzegovina has completed two trials in the Stanković and Janković cases, three trials are ongoing and one case is at the pre-trial stage. The International Tribunal is satisfied that the two completed trials respected international norms of due process as recognized by reports prepared by the OSCE and by human rights organizations.
I must however emphasize that, in order for our completion strategy to succeed and for local judiciaries to carry on the legacy of the International Tribunal, it is vital that the international community maintain its support for capacity-building of judicial institutions in the region. A lot of work remains to be done if these courts are to successfully continue the mission of the International Tribunal in the future. By way of illustration, there is a desperate need to ensure adequate detention facilities for remand and convicted accused. Much also remains to be achieved in the training of police and prison officers on due process and human rights standards. Improvements in the quality of cooperation between States of the region in the investigation and prosecution of alleged war criminals are also called for.
The International Tribunal has recently taken the initiative to strengthen cooperation and to facilitate the work of our domestic counterparts, especially in the former Yugoslavia, through the adoption of an amendment to Rule 75 of the Rules of Procedure and Evidence that allows judicial authorities in other jurisdictions, or parties duly authorised by an appropriate judicial authority, to petition the International Tribunal directly for access to confidential material. The timeliness of this amendment was evidenced by the fact that, shortly after its adoption, judicial authorities in Bosnia and Herzegovina quickly petitioned the International Tribunal for such access, thus further reinforcing our existing partnership.
Furthermore, as explained in greater detail in the Report, Judges of the International Tribunal have continued to share their expertise and experiences with members of the judiciaries in the former Yugoslavia. Our Outreach Programme has also pursued its efforts to make the work of the International Tribunal more accessible and intelligible to the various communities in the former Yugoslavia.
Turning to the question of State cooperation. I must report that, on this question, there has indeed been some progress. It is undeniable that the fact that two fugitives, Tolimir and Đorđević, were recently arrested and transferred to the International Tribunal for trial is a very encouraging development. However, I must still regretfully note the failure to secure the arrest and transfer of the four remaining high level fugitives, namely Karadzić, Mladić, Župlijanin and Haždić.
With the establishment of the International Tribunal, the international community sent an unequivocal message that impunity for serious violations of international humanitarian law would no longer be tolerated. In the current global context, we cannot afford to jeopardize this fundamental principle and let these four fugitives evade justice. The success of the International Tribunal depends on the willingness of States to cooperate with the International Tribunal in full compliance with their obligation do so under Article 29 of the Statute. At this point, the necessity of full cooperation has reached a critical stage. I therefore must restate that the International Tribunal should not close its doors before these fugitives are arrested and tried. I urge the Security Council to make it clear that the trial of these fugitives by the international community does not hinge upon the International Tribunal's proposed Completion Strategy dates. I also reiterate my call to all States to do all within their power to ensure the arrest of these fugitives immediately.
With respect to the question of the International Tribunal's residual mechanisms that will have to remain in place after all trials and appeals on the International Tribunal's docket are completed, let me give you the following update. Two joint reports were submitted by the International Tribunal and the ICTR in December 2006 and April 2007, respectively. After receiving comments from Member States, we submitted a final report to the Office of Legal Affairs in September 2007 and are pursuing our work with the Security Council Working Group on the ad hoc International Tribunals on this matter.
I finally wish to underscore that the International Tribunal's commitment to meeting completion strategy deadlines has remained steadfast. In presenting the report to you today I have noted some of the results achieved in terms of efficiency; efficiency which has not come at the expense of upholding fundamental due process standards. The slippage in previously projected completion dates has occurred for reasons out of our control, that is, the late arrest of the two fugitives recently transferred to the International Tribunal at a time where their case could no longer be joined with other pending proceedings. One year ago, I had already urged the Security Council to take action to arrest immediately the remaining fugitives and warned that any delays in this regard would seriously undermine the International Tribunal's ability to meet Completion Strategy dates. The failure to arrest the remaining four fugitives will inevitably lead to further delays. If those fugitives are arrested now, some but not all, may be eligible for joinder with pending proceedings. However, any delays in their arrest will necessarily result in separate trials, which will cause additional adjustments to the currently projected completion strategy deadlines.
I shall add that we have already considered the conditions which would allow us to limit to the greatest extent possible the impact of late arrests on projected deadlines, and to maintain the same level of productivity during most of 2008 and 2009. One such condition is actually already met. One of the on-going trials will enter the judgement drafting phase by the end of January 2008, earlier than expected, creating thereby courtroom availability. Two more cases currently at trial will successively move to the drafting phase, enabling us to start an additional trial in February 2008. We currently have the necessary staffing resources to support such level of trial activity. As far as judges are concerned, one Permanent Judge, who expects to deliver a Judgement in December of this year, would be available to start a new case, and could finalize the pre-trial phase of that case by early 2008. At that point, two solutions could be envisaged with respect to ad litem Judges, both of which would require the Council's intervention. First, the statutory three years' term of current ad litem Judges, who would accept to sit in a second trial, could be extended for the time required to complete it. Another option would be to appoint additional ad litem judges, thus temporarily increasing the number of ad litem Judges above twelve. The number of ad litem judges will return to twelve, as provided under the Statute, as soon as the first multi-accused trial is completed, which is foreseen for September 2008. The new ad litem Judges would be assigned to the eighth trial with the understanding that they would have to sit in a second trial before the first comes to an end. Should the Security Council decide to consider either of these two options, I would be able to provide a chart reflecting their impact on the schedule of trials.
As I conclude, I must emphasize that the success of the International Tribunal's legacy cannot be measured only by the judgements it has issued or by the number of trials and appeals completed. Obviously, the real measure of its success lies in the invaluable precedent it has set for the enforcement of international humanitarian law and the contribution it has made to the restoration of peace and stability in the former Yugoslavia. Indeed, after having developed and expanded international humanitarian law, it was essential for the international community to see these norms enforced and to affirm that those responsible for serious violations of international humanitarian law would not enjoy impunity.
Your Excellencies, the International Tribunal has clearly demonstrated that international justice can be efficient without sacrificing due process standards. In the last two years, we have constantly developed creative approaches, which have proved particularly effective in meeting these goals as well as completion strategy objectives. It is now for the Council to renew its support to the International Tribunal's mission and to the successful completion of its work.
Mr. President, Your Excellencies, I thank you for the attention and the time that you have given to me today.
***** |